Skip to content
Social Security Online
Press Releases
Press Office Home SSA logo: link to Social Security Online home

Statement on Second Flawed Report from Syracuse University

Meet the Press Office Skip links
Facts And Figures
Press Releases
PSAs for Radio
PSAs for Television
Congressional Testimonies
SSA Reports
SSA Research
Monday, July 4, 2011 Press Office
For Immediate Release 410-965-8904


News Release

Statement on Second Flawed Report from Syracuse University

Syracuse's latest "analysis" is just more unsupportable grandstanding masquerading as academic research.  Federal law gives Administrative Law Judges substantial decisional independence in making their decisions, so variations between judges are a predictable consequence of Congressional decisions.

As with Syracuse's last report on Social Security, this one also is riddled with methodological sloppiness.  For instance, without other changes, a 30% increase in judges is going to increase the number of judges who are outliers at both ends of the spectrum, so simply comparing the range does not mean that decisions overall are more variable than in recent years. 

Syracuse also continues to compare apples and oranges.  For instance, National Hearing Centers (NHC) hear a rapidly changing mix of cases by video – one judge hearing cases from Anchorage while the judge next door is hearing cases from Puerto Rico.  Accordingly, it is irresponsible for Syracuse, as it does on page 5, to compare judges in an NHC with judges in a standard hearing office without accounting for the substantial differences in the age and origin of the cases.

We call on Syracuse University to insist that reports of this nature receive thorough peer review to end misleading errors, and to fully disclose the sources of funding for its reports.  Academic integrity requires no less.

# # #

SSA Press Office  440 Altmeyer Building  6401 Security Blvd.  Baltimore, MD 21235
410-965-8904  FAX 410-966-9973

 Link to Government Made Easy Privacy Policy | Website Policies & Other Important Information | Site Map
Need Larger Text?